Take the 2-minute tour ×
Sports Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for participants in team and individual sport activities. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Right arm spinners are either off spinners or leg spinners. But left arm spinners are refered to as chinaman and orthodox. They are never refered to as off spinners or leg spinners. Why are left arm spinners called differently?

share|improve this question

2 Answers 2

Why are left arm spinners called differently?

To appropriately describe how the ball is bowled (right-handed or left-handed).


For right-arm bowlers, off spinners spin from off to leg and leg spinners spin from leg to off.

For left-arm bowlers, "off spinners" spin from leg to off and "leg spinners" spin from off to leg, which is opposite of what is stated above.

left-arm orthodox spin

Left-arm off spinners are known as "left-arm orthodox." It spins from leg to off, is bowled left-armed, and uses a finger spin technique. (1)

leg spin

A leg spinner also spins from leg to off, but is bowled right-armed and uses a wrist spin technique. (1)

As you can see, calling a spinner by how it spins only describes such. It does not describe how it was bowled (the bowler's handedness).

share|improve this answer
3  
Hmm... in that case, I have another question. Why are right arm spinners refered by the direction of spin (off/leg), and left arm spinners by the technique of bowling? –  Max Sep 25 '12 at 14:44
    
In formal setting, like tables of published cricket stats, the nomenclature is sometimes stated as 'hand-style'. So 'right arm orthodox spin' or 'left arm wrist spin'. I personally really hate that left arm wrist spinners are still, in this day and age, referred to as 'chinamen', but it's pretty ingrained in the lingo of the game. –  Bogdanovist Oct 10 '12 at 3:40

It is ultimately a naming convention for convenience.

There are by nature more right-handers, both bowlers and batsmen, so it makes some sense that the default, most compact terminology -- offspinner and legspinner -- is made relative to that combination.

Also, there are more finger spinners than wrist spinners (by nature?), so it makes some sense that among left armers the default, most compact terminology is assigned to the finger spinners.

Also, arguably, bowling left-arm wrist spin is less likely to be successful as a career, because it's harder to do than finger spinning, and you're effectively bowling offspin to the mostly right-handed batsmen, which is less difficult to deal with than legspin. So as a result of this being on average the least natural way to bowl and possibly the least effective, left-arm wrist spinners are so rare at the top level that they get the most obscure term.

If you want to use a methodical and neutral terminology, you can refer to any traditional spin bowler as right/left-arm finger/wrist spin, but try saying that all day long. And nowadays, with the rise of "mystery spinners", this categorization is starting to break down, and you will see bowlers listed as "leg break/googly" or some such.

(A similar asymmetry exists in baseball, where left-handers are referred to as "southpaws", but there is no common special term for right-handers.)

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.