Take the 2-minute tour ×
Sports Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for participants in team and individual sport activities. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I've noticed that Thomas Müller of Germany wears very small shin guards (at least most of the time). If I remember correctly he did the same thing during the last world cup or Euros. I played a bit of soccer when I was young and can't understand why a professional player would refuse to wear shin guards that cover all their shins. They are the only thing that keep you away from seriously hurting your shins and going through ridiculous pain. So what's the reason behind this? Why would you leave a considerable amount of your shins unprotected and risk getting injured??

share|improve this question
    
Given that it is a requirement that players wear shinguards, and equipment is usually carefully checked at the professional level of the game, I believe it is very unlikely that Thomas Müller doesn't wear shinguards all the time while playing. –  studro Jun 23 '14 at 0:22
    
I've seen that happen too many times. I'll try to find a picture and post it –  alamoot Jun 23 '14 at 0:43
    
Anecdotal evidence, but some players say even light and small shinguards restrict their movement. I wear very large and thick shinguards, and I don't find this to be the case, so I guess it comes down to personal opinion. Obviously some players would risk being told they cannot play by the referee, or worse a broken leg rather than the apparent decrease in ability that comes from wearing shinguards. –  studro Jun 23 '14 at 4:39
    
I went over a lot pf pictures of him and it seems like he wears small shin guards at the very bottom of his shins, thus having the upper half of his shins exposed during games –  alamoot Jun 23 '14 at 15:06
    
Perhaps you could edit the question to ask why players wear small shinguards that quite obviously do not protect them adequately, if that's what you want answered instead. However, I think it's likely to lead to a lot of personal opinion and conjecture, but you might luck out and find a good answer. –  studro Jun 24 '14 at 0:30

3 Answers 3

up vote -1 down vote accepted

The most important reason: It's simply a question of style. Like Cristiano Ronaldo wears long socks, some others are wearing sweatbands, ...

Besides, it's not very comfortable to wear shin guards. One sweats heavily underneath them. In personal, because of this reason, I'm wearing my shin guards only during the game. Never during training, warm-up or even a training match.

In addition, most injuries around the shin guards take place lower (ankle) or above them (knee).

share|improve this answer
    
There are two problems with this answer. The second paragraph claims that it is not very comfortable to wear shinpads. It's not entirely clear that this is purely opinion. The third paragraph is not an opinion, so it should really be removed unless it can be supported with a reference. –  studro Jan 11 at 22:24

Introduction

I have played soccer for more than 20 years, since I was kid my parents tought me to use shinguards. This will be the first equipment they bought me.

Sometimes I have forgotten to use or in a hurry, and have received injuries like fissures/small fracture for bone and muscle in the shin area.

Last time I was injured, after doing a legal slide tackle, a team mate stepped over the side of my shin with his bodyweight resulting in my lateral shin got fisured, I was wearing decent shinguards but received impact on least protected side and some plastic cleats made direct contact to my leg. After this injury I will get an elite protective shinguard model Diadora Gamma Carbonio, which is the model made for Francesco Totti after he received serious injury bone fracture prior to 2006 World Cup. (Price $150 not more expensive than a cast at hospital and more than a month without playing! Medical bill less complicated fracture = $2500 if surgery required = $35000 + )

Diadora Gamma C. http://www.amazon.com/Diadora-Gamma-Carbinio-Shin-Guard/dp/B0074GQ9N0

Francesco Toti minute 5:18 someone steps on his leg World Cup 2006 just after fracture comeback , 6:18 he is fine and shows his new specially designed Diadora shinguards. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DXNpNHvZWv0

Answer:

Why do some pro players use such small shinguards, same reason amateur players either dont use or use small shinguards. They have acquired a BAD HABBIT . Fifa doesnt regulate the size of the shinguard. Its true with time and small hits bone gets more resistant, but some hard hits or players steping on your leg are very dangerous.

I think there should be more strict rules on the size of shinguards worn, even though maybe some will say more protection can result in more rough dangerous play, like NFL American football for example, but the shin is a very sensible area, even without fracture injury a hit on an exposed area can get you out for the rest of the game.

Even if you yourself while kicking hit accidentaly another player with your shin, you can easily get injured. I have seen broken shins while in Karate practice and tournament for example a guy kicked, amd opponent raised elbow to protect, resulting in fractured leg. OUCH Horrible injury to watch.

------------ Conclusion

I have learned my lesson , I dont play nor train without appropiate shinguards . For me a well designed and securely fit shinguard ain't uncomfortable at all, I also like to use classic leather shoes. I run very fast I dont care if I have and extra pound on my legs, you must be faster than me to catch me. ;)

P.S. I am also an amateur "semipro" long distance runner. 5K - 17 minutes

share|improve this answer
  • Shin-guards provide superficial protection at best. If someone makes a really bad foul on you, they are not going to protect bones from being broken.

  • Professional footballplayers are used to getting hit on the shins over and over again. Pain is temporary, and something you get used to.

  • Many players train without shin-guards. Probably they feel that shin-guards constrict their movement

  • I for one feel they hamper movement and ball-control

share|improve this answer
1  
I cannot agree with point 1, as I would argue that the majority of collisions with the shin in a match indeed are superficial, therefore it is very important to minimise the effects of these collisions. Since these are fair challenges, they are mitigated by the players wearing shinguards. "Really bad fouls" are relatively rare, and as such are mitigated by sending the offender off. Point 2 is also defeated by this argument. Point 3 seems like the correct train of thought, but you probably should add a source/reference to back this claim up. –  studro Jul 1 '14 at 6:47

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.