3

I was watching a game between the Blue Jays and the Rangers and several times the ball was clearly in the strike zone, but balls were called and vice versa. The Blue Jays coach was furious and got sent off after the 3rd inning.

My question is the following. When an umpire has a very inconsistent strike zone that, does the league offer any recourse for teams to challenge this? Do they not have access to video reviews for these kind of calls?

8

Rule 9.02 in the MLB Rule Book covers judgment calls made by the umpire (which includes determining whether a pitch was a ball or strike). What is not reviewable is covered in a MLB FAQ.

In short, this type of judgment call is not subject to objection1 or review2. If there is reasonable doubt, the manager may appeal the decision3 as a recourse. Then, umpires may consult4 to make a final determination.

1 - Rule 9.02a, 2 - aforementioned MLB FAQ, 3 - Rule 9.02b, 4 - Rule 9.02c

2
  • I don't think you can appeal a strike/ball call. No other umpire has position to have a useful opinion. I suppose you could protest the game, but it's unlikely that could possibly have any impact unless you found evidence the umpire was bribed or betting on the game or something extraordinary like that.
    – Joe
    May 20 '16 at 19:17
  • The contentious nature of this particular issue in recent history makes me think something is gonna change here. Statcast proves that the level of accuracy available with computers surpasses that available to human eyes. It might take 10 years or more, but it's coming.
    – dgo
    May 20 '16 at 21:17
2

There is no immediate recourse, as mentioned by Mastermind_Ed, but, long term, if there is an issue, a team can let the league know they have concerns, and the officials are constantly having their work reviewed, graded and evaluated (as they are in all sports at almost all levels). If an umpire can't consistently call balls and strikes, they will be replaced and will not be assigned to those duties at that level.

Letting the league know one has concerns, especially with today's technology in looking at where the ball crosses the plate in relation to the strike zone, can probably bring attention to and accelerate a review where necessary.

2
  • I'm not so sure about your thoughts re last half of the first paragraph ... cough .... cough .... Hernandez ... cough.
    – CGCampbell
    Jun 7 at 15:49
  • @CGCampbell - well, in regards to my claiming they do take note of that, Hernandez was denied promotions and elite assignments enough that he tried to sue MLB claiming it was racial/ethnic discrimination, and he lost, so, clearly, issues are not being ignored. Jun 9 at 13:42

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.