5

A common advice in golf is to keep your left arm straight. (The terminology used here is for right hand players.) For some players it is possible to compromise slightly with this advice and still hit balls reasonably. But if you look at top players, the majority will adhere to the standard.

The movement in baseball batting is very similar to the golf swing. A rotation of the body core is transferred to the arms and bat/club.

But in baseball batting, keeping your left arm straight is not considered an important part of the technique, to my knowledge. (I have no deeper knowledge of baseball, though.)

What is the reason for this difference in technique? (A baseball bat is about 3 times as heavy as a golf driver. But that is not an explanation in itself.)

The reason why the left arm should be kept straight in golf is often said to be the increase in swing radius obtained, producing longer shots. If this is the only/major reason remains to be proven, in my opinion.

1

This is just an opinion from the television viewer.

I think the big difference between the two swing techniques comes from the ball to hit:

  • In golf, the ball is stationary on the ground near the player, so the player has the time to prepare the shot and he know where to hit. It is important to hit the golf ball at a determined distance from the body (so the straight arm tends to fix the distance from the hand to the ball).
  • In baseball, the ball arrives at a speed of 60 to 100 miles per hour and the distance from the player to the incoming ball does not allow the player to have such precise preparation. The baseball player needs more flexibility in the arm when trying to hit the ball. Furthermore, the baseball player does not need to hit the ball with the end of the bat, and he can use a wider portion of a bat unlike a golf club.
  • Thanks for the reply. I think you could present one possible factor, so I just up voted your reply. Based on deductive knowledge I think one can say that with slightly flexed arms, the batsman is more prepared for different situations and positions to make contact. (I would say I have a reasonable knowledge of the golf swing, but I admit I do not know baseball, though. But similarities in the movements are often described.) – ycc_swe Aug 26 '16 at 11:21
  • 1
    @ycc_swe Swings for golf and baseball are completely different. If they are, all baseball players will be a good golf player, or vice versa. They are more often than not not. You can watch some youtube videos and see the impact point and what players do to maximize the impact. – user10632 Aug 26 '16 at 11:42
  • @Rathony What I have seen so far is that baseball players rotate the hips more vigorously through impact. That I explain as delivering more energy to the bat which is heavier than a golf club. The plane of the swings are different of course. The plane of the golf swing is steeper, the arms are lifted on the top of the backswing. But basically there are many similarities. Jimmy Ballard used to coach both types of players. Baseball players are not automatically good golfers and the reverse. ... – ycc_swe Aug 26 '16 at 11:47
  • ... There are so many more factors involved. But my guess is the baseball batter would quickly learn to hit a golf ball far and the reverse. But there are many guys that can strike the golf ball far but do not score well. – ycc_swe Aug 26 '16 at 11:47
5

One thing to consider here is that hitting a baseball is a reaction move and hitting a golf ball is not.

Having 15+ years of golf experience, one reason why top golfers will "adhere to the standard" is for consistency and reliability. As different as golf swings are (eg, Jim Furyk, Bubba Watson, Rory McIlroy), players are similar at different points of the golf swing, especially impact. The "increase in swing radius" is a minor benefit compared to consistently and reliably hitting a golf ball long and straight.

Having played a season of ASA slow-pitch softball, using the same swing as I do in golf isn't feasible. If you go into the batter's box (with your heels as close to the boundary as possible), face the plate, and reach your left arm straight, the handle of the bat (or, at best, the middle of the bat) will be over the strike zone. You want the barrel of the bat to hit the baseball.

Yes, both swings use similar concepts (utilize the core, unwind, transfer to the arms), but both swings are used under different scenarios (reaction in baseball vs. stationary in golf) and for different locations (variably waist-high in baseball vs. constantly at your feet in golf).


If Miguel Cabrera was hitting a golf ball or if Bubba Watson was hitting a baseball, it is evident that body position will be different as a result to adjust to where they need to make contact.

Miguel Cabrera

Bubba Watson

  • I feel pretty certain that the baseball players are mostly much more open at impact (that is what golfers say when we mean that the shoulders (and hips) have rotated towards the target) The baseball players sometimes almost look out on the field when they make contact with the ball. / There is also a difference in build. Some very slim (usually tallish though) top players can hit the ball far, but in baseball all players seem more "heavily built" to my eye? Is that a cultural thing or is all due to the extra pound pound of weight on a bat compared to a golf club? :) – ycc_swe Aug 26 '16 at 12:52
  • 1
    @ycc_swe Take my response with a grain of salt, but that deduces that baseball uses more of the "big" muscles (ie, upper body) for power whereas golfers use flexibility for power. In general, in order to be more flexible, muscles are leaner. If muscles are bigger in golf, that robs swing speed and range of motion, thus losing power. – user527 Aug 26 '16 at 12:56
  • Yes it is interesting. I haven't followed golf for a while. But I would say Bubba is reverse pivoting on that picture. Weight still on left foot at impact. Like Olazabal in the old days, but grip looks stronger. Unusual swing deviation at top level. You feel a lot of arm and hand action coming through there. – ycc_swe Aug 26 '16 at 13:06
2

One more good reason to keep your left arm straight on a golf shot: precision.

In baseball, a long-term batting average of .300 is pretty darn good. That's slightly less than one in three at-bats resulting in a batted ball good enough to get the player on base without some error by the defending team. Additionally, out of however many pitches a batter will see in a season (let's say they see an average of five per at-bat, an average of 4 at-bats in a game, times 162 regular-season games, so somewhere in the neighborhood of 3,200 pitches per season), the home-run record is 73 in a regular season, and that guy admitted to steroid use. So in a record-setting performance, a baseball player will hit about 2% of the pitches he sees over the wall, and will hit a home run in just over 1 out of every 10 at-bats.

A golfer who hits the same percentage of "good shots" (up in the air and in the general direction the player intended), even using the higher one-in-ten statistic to make up for the fact that the ball isn't moving, or even the one-in-three statistic just to be exceedingly generous regarding the number of variables inherent in the batters job versus the golfer's, would be asked to leave the course after three holes, for tearing up the fairways and slowing other players. The best baseball players can do is simply nowhere near good enough in terms of ball striking precision to even show up at the golf course. The golfer, on every shot, is expected to hit a ball 1.625" in diameter using a club with a sweet spot about as big as the ball itself, on the end of a shaft that can be up to 6 inches longer than a baseball bat. Not only do they have to do that, but every shot is expected to be accurate to the level of Babe Ruth's famous called shot (within a section of bleachers), otherwise it's seen as a miss.

That is the level of precision professional golfers require just to end up with a par score, much less to find the extra 10-15 shots over 4 rounds of golf needed to win a tournament. Their technique, therefore, requires precision over power. A straight left arm keeps the swing closer to a single plane, and more importantly, brings the clubhead right back to where it was at address, which is the biggest aid to precision that a golfer can give himself.

  • I learn about baseball all the time :) I agree with you. A straight arm is a position easy to reproduce. Wearmarks are impressive. But even golf professionals break the swing plane, lifting the arms at the end of the backswing and coming back in the downswing. / And the shoulders being more open at impact than at address. But they hit it at the sweet spot, every time! – ycc_swe Oct 11 '16 at 5:54
1

Adding to Ale's great answer, you should note the following big difference between golf and baseball:

  1. In golf, it's like you place a ball where your club touches the ground. You must have watched pro golfers doing a practice swing before hitting the ball. The practice swing is necessary because they need to check the distance between the ball and their hands. The distance should be measured as exactly as possible so that such a small ball could be hit with a tiny sweet spot in a golf club. That's why golf players keep their left arms straight. You have to note that players don't keep their left arm straight when they play with shorter clubs for shorter distance. They keep their arms connected to the body. In other words, the longer distance you want to hit, the more straight you should keep your left arm.

  2. In baseball, you swing your bat towards an incoming ball. If a pitched ball comes outside, you can keep your left arm straight trying to hit it with the barrel. If it comes far outside, you will most likely hit the ball with the cap (end of the bat). That's when you have the maximum distance between an incoming ball and your body with a bat. However, if a ball comes inside the pitch zone, you could have a problem if you keep your left arm straight. You can never hit the ball with the barrel with your left arm straight and the handle will most likely hit the ball, which could break the bat.

For more information, you can watch the linked YouTube video, Robert Garrigus golf swing versus Barry Bonds.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.