After watching the US-Canada Women's gold medal match, where the Canadian's had 30 seconds remaining in a power play following the end of the last period, I have to ask a question. If you know that a shootout is likely, why doesn't one team use their weakest shooter, who would suffer a penalty, to slam into the opposing team's best shooter with the hope of causing a performance-impacting injury? Of course, this would not be a respectable action, but, other than sportsmanship, what reason is there to not field this strategy? Sure the advantage gained for the shootout may be nominal, but even a tiny error in skating or handling can cause a shooter or goalie to miss.



  • Most people have morals.
  • Anyone which was ever found to have been involved in this (the players, the coaches, the team management) would immediately receive life bans from the IIHF.
  • This would probably also be criminal assault in many jurisdictions.
  • Players don't want to start this kind of thing - they could be the next one on the end of an intentional injury.
  • Pierre de Coubertin once said something about winning.
  • So many more reasons.
| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    Thanks. Those are all reasons that I agree with but do not explain why it would be a poor strategy. Getting found out would probably be unlikely-many hits are tolerated and certainly, no one would record that they chose that as a strategy, which makes the assault point a stretch (although I agree that this SHOULD count as assault). In some situations, such as the famous Canada-Soviet games, where the tension between the competing countries is high, all of them, this kind of decision may be easy to make. Bitter hatred does throw a wrench in most peoples' moral reasoning. – RougeSegwayUser Feb 22 '18 at 9:00
  • 3
    Players can also go to jail for this.. Dino Ciccarelli did (for a different kind of assault on the ice, but it's certainly possible). – dly Feb 22 '18 at 15:24

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.