5

Recently, when FC Barcelona signed Arthur from Brazil, reports regarding another new signing Yerry Mina being sent on loan due to some foreign player restrictions surfaced. What is this rule and do similar rules exist in Europe's other top leagues?

4

La Liga

La Liga regulations permit up to three "foreign" players per team.

"Foreign" refers to a player from outside the European Union. Due to a legal ruling over a German handball player, there are exceptions for people from countries with EU association agreements (because a quota that counts them is a restriction on their employment opportunity contrary to such an agreement).

Players with ancestry of an EU country may also use this to be counted as an EU player, and therefore not as foreign. For example, Argentine players of Italian descent have used this method to avoid the quota.


Other Countries

Germany's Bundesliga 1 and 2 do not have a maximum foreign player limit, but instead a minimum "local" player limit. At least 8 players must have played for the club in three seasons each before turning 25, and at least 4 further players must have done the same at any German club.

France's Ligue 1 appears to have a limit of five foreign players (with a similar meaning as above) and further allows only four to be playing on the field at any time. However sources on this are unclear as to whether the five is actually four (and thus the second limit is unnecessary). Actual regulations are not easy to find.

English Premier League currently requires a minimum of 6 "home-grown" players in the match list of 18, which is expected to rise to 7 and additionally require a "club-grown" player in 2018-19.

Notably this rule explicitly disregards nationality or citizenship. Such players must have played three seasons or three years for an English or Welsh-affiliated club before or during the year they turn 21.

  • By "German handball player", do you mean Maroš Kolpak? If so, he was Slovakian (the case was in Germany). – Philip Kendall Apr 7 '18 at 15:54
  • But he was playing German handball... – Nij Apr 7 '18 at 20:21
  • 3
    That's an atypical use of English at best. Nobody would ever describe (say) Paul Pogba as an "English football player" just because he happens to play in England at the moment. – Philip Kendall Apr 7 '18 at 20:25
3

In Spanish La Liga there's a rule ⁽¹⁾ ⁽²⁾ ⁽³⁾ which states that each club can have up to 3 non-EU players (players from African, Caribbean and Pacific Group of States are excluded from that rule).

Currently, 3 spots are reserved for Philippe Coutinho, Paulinho and Yerry Mina (Other originally non-EU players, namely Messi worked more than 5 years in Spain and acquired Spanish citizenship; Suarez has Italian citizenship through his wife). Now, if Arthur joins the club, someone has to either leave or gain European citizenship. There are rumors that Coutinho will apply for Portuguese citizenship through his wife to free up one space.


The foreign player quotas of other top European leagues are well documented in @Nij's answer. These discriminating quota rules are actually not just a football thing and are practiced in other sports as well. Here you can find a paper by M. Greenberg and J. Gray "Citizenship Based Quota Systems in Athletics" which describes some citizenship based quota systems in sports and their expected effects on competitiveness.

  • I think any mention of competitiveness has missed the point of such quotas, which is to variously foster domestic player strength and fan engagement and national program support. I failed to note any significant mention of competitiveness in the paper itself as well, which is unsurprising given that (I believe) it only attempts to survey the current and historic legal situation around various quotas. – Nij Apr 7 '18 at 6:19

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.