1

Commonly, before a broadcast football game you will see the positions of each team's players on the field. Now since this can't be enforced as a rule, wouldn't it be strategically benificial that coaches lie about who's playing where ? Although the names of the players composing the squad are verifiable, their actual positions aren't. Does this ever happen ?

Typical pre-match TV display

  • 2
    The only people who would care are spectators and broadcasters. Teams don't typically change their default/basic formation from week to week. This wouldn't help the team at all. – Nij Aug 15 '18 at 5:47
2

It'a actually as simple as the broadcasters making an educated guess based on previous matches. If a team is playing the same four defenders as the previous match, the broadcaster assumes the team is still playing a back four with players in the same positions. Uefa do this as well with their teamsheets.

There are often occasions where play starts and the commentators point out x team are actually playing a back five, for example, if this formation was unexpected beforehand.

3

Actually the coaches usually don't talk to the press about their formation at all. So there's no need to lie.

At least in the DFL and DFB rules there is a clear procedure, because it's done online (for almost any official competition in Germany, including the Bundesliga):

  • Team A reports their team (starting 11 + subs, goalkeeper, captain)
  • Team B reports theirs
  • When both teams have confirmed their team it will be locked automatically and made available to the officials and the opposing team
  • In the pro leagues the home team now has to take care that the press gets a (printed) copy (usually done by a media representative). They usually look like this:

enter image description here Example match report taken from the handbook

So since there is no official report about the exact formation we can safely assume that the formation on the screen is a good guess based on past games and the position players usually play. Sometimes the coach talks about the formation (something like "We'll play 4-3-3." without mentioning names) in the press conference before a game, but usually they don't.

  • Considering there's a fair chance they would get it wrong quite often, especially in international football with its substantial turnaround, the chances of revealing incorrect information to the audience seem to me to be a bit too high to risk it. – James Well Aug 15 '18 at 19:54

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.