0

A batter hits the ball really high and runs the bases to home plate. However, one of the defending players catches the ball after the batter crosses home plate and the ball never touches the ground.

Would it be considered a flyout or a home run?

4

Kad's answer is correct -- any ball that has not touched the ground and is caught, regardless of the runner's position, is out by flyout. However, I wanted to challenge the premise of the question.

This is an impossible scenario

This could never happen in any baseball game due to the physics of a flyball. For example, this question has an answer for one of the highest flyballs from the 2019 season by Joey Gallo. That flyball went over 200 feet up and had a hang time of 7.3 seconds. My search results have yielded similar numbers for a top hang time for a flyball -- somewhere between 7 and 8 seconds in the air. I'm no physics major, but even when factoring in spin, altitude, and an exceptionally hard-hit ball -- you aren't going to exceed 10 seconds of hang time on a flyball.

This HuffPost article breaks down the ideal path around the bases and the time required to do so. They conclude that the ideal path would result in a total time of 16.7 seconds to round the bases.

The total time around the bases is about 16.7 seconds assuming maximum acceleration 10 feet per second per second, about 25 percent faster than following the baseline for 22.2 seconds (coming to a full stop at first, second, and third base), and about 6 percent faster than following a circular path for 17.8 seconds.

In fact, they provide the Guinness World Record for the fastest run around the base path.

The record time according to Guiness[sic] is 13.3 seconds, set by Evar Swanson in Columbus, Ohio, in 1932. His average speed around the bases was about 27 feet per second.

So even at world record speed with the maximum height on a fly ball, you would still be unable to complete the run prior to the ball being caught.

  • Good point about the impossibility - you'd have to hit the ball to a height of over 700 feet to get a hang time of 13.3 seconds, very well beyond the record height of 200-300 feet. – Nuclear Wang Aug 27 '19 at 15:25
  • 2
    You could hit a ball onto one of the central Tropicana catwalks. If it rolled around for a few seconds and then fell off, it could delay it enough while still remaining in play. Never happened to my knowledge, but almost possible. I'll bet umps wouldn't wait 10 seconds before calling the ball dead though. – BowlOfRed Aug 27 '19 at 15:55
2

He would be out. A home run is defined by a batter circling the bases in one play without being put out. Since the ball would still be in play even if he circled the bases, catching it would be an out.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.