0

A guy is explaining some unwritten rules in baseball. At about 8'01″ into the video, it sounds like that the guy says

Pitchers should never show up their fielders

What does "show up" mean there?

Video:

3

To show someone up is defined as:

to do something that embarrasses someone or makes someone seem stupid

In baseball, if a fielder makes an error, or doesn't get to a ball they may have been able to get to, it's considered inappropriate for the pitcher to complain about it or otherwise make it clear the fielder screwed up. The assumption is that the fielder knows they screwed up, and the pitcher should not pile on; instead, they should keep doing their own job.

This isn't really any different from any other workplace, to be honest; it's inappropriate to point out others' mistakes in public in general.

The video, though, seems to imply something else - that pitchers should not "show up" the fielders by making better plays than them? That's not a real unwritten rule of baseball, and in fact pitchers who make great plays are celebrated (shameless plug for my favorite play all-time, seen in person:

). What is true is that pitchers shouldn't try to make a play on a high fly ball that another player can easily get to, but that's because they're not particularly skilled at catching fly balls, compared to the fielder who is (and for traffic control purposes - the SS or sometimes the 2B is in charge of pop flys in the middle of the infield, as they can see the whole field and are presumably the best fielder.)

6
  • Lol, wasn't sure that video would actually come up like that in an answer, good to know it does!
    – Joe
    Sep 9 '20 at 14:56
  • To "show someone up" is a bit more specific, meaning that you embarrassed someone by outperforming them. A pitcher that gripes about a fielder's error is not showing them up, since the pitcher didn't do anything better. A pitcher that snags a line drive which another fielder could have gotten might be considered showing them up, but I agree I've never heard of this unwritten rule. Sep 9 '20 at 14:59
  • @NuclearWang (shrug) The dictionary doesn't agree, and I have definitely heard it used both ways. But you're certainly welcome to provide a separate answer if you like!
    – Joe
    Sep 9 '20 at 16:07
  • I do wonder, though, if the video is not intended to be taken seriously. :)
    – Joe
    Sep 9 '20 at 16:08
  • Thanks for your answer. In "the video, though, seems to imply something else", does the video refer to "2010/04/05 Buehrle's backhand play" or "Baseball Rules of Engagement"?
    – JJJohn
    Sep 10 '20 at 7:28

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.