How does the NFL prevent a team on the last week of the season to losing on purpose ensuring a #1 draft pick for the following year?
-
Similar question about NBA: Has a team ever lost on purpose to get better draft picks? And about NHL: Is there any rule forcing a team to try to win?– MartinDec 29, 2021 at 14:48
-
nypost.com/2019/02/07/why-tanking-in-the-nfl-is-barely-existent– BowlOfRedJan 4, 2022 at 9:36
-
@BowlOfRed It would be great if you could summarise the contents of that link into an answer :-)– Philip Kendall ♦Jan 5, 2022 at 10:18
2 Answers
This isn't the reason but a reason: Player Incentives.
Late in the season, players are close to reaching incentives that would reward them in bonus money if they were to reach said incentives. This provides an incentive to be productive, even if the team is also in a spot to get the #1 pick in the draft.
Now, that doesn't stop a team effort from tanking. However, players may rebel at such a notion. An example of this is Doug Pederson and the Philadelphia Eagles at the end of 2020. The Eagles were out of playoff contention and lost to the Football Team.
I'm not sure prevention is necessary. Generally at the end of the year you have two or three teams in a "race to the bottom". But such teams have a strong motivation not to lose:
- Teams are very competitive by nature. No one enjoys losing.
- Coaches with poorly-performing teams risk being fired. Winning improves their prospects.
- For players in this injury-riddled sport, the earnings window is very short. They get paid, either by their current team or their next team, based on their on-field performance. Players play hard to show their value.
I have one data point which may illustrate. Gary Kubiak coached the Denver Broncos during the 2016-17 season. He had won the Superbowl coaching the Broncos in 2015-16. The Broncos were 8-7 heading into the final game of the 2016 season. They had been eliminated from the playoffs. Losing would have meant better draft picks the next Spring. The Broncos played their starters against the Raiders (who had playoff positioning at stake) and beat them 24-6.
-
1Your example isn't great as the value of draft picks drops off rapidly; while the difference between the 1st and 2nd draft picks can be enormous, while the difference being the 16th and 17th is much smaller. Can you give an example where a team in contention for the 1st pick in the draft won on the last day of the season?– Philip Kendall ♦Dec 30, 2021 at 15:43
-
There might be an example, or their might not be ... teams in contention for the 1st pick in the draft didn't win many games, period.– jsf80238Dec 30, 2021 at 15:47