On January 8 2023, the Buffalo Bills scored a touchdown on kickoff return. Nyheim Hines returned the ball, then ran very near the sideline. Shortly before reaching the end zone, he spread his arms so that the ball was outside the field. After entering the end zone with the ball still being outside the field, he threw the ball away. From my perspective, it looked like the ball only crossed the goal line after Nyheim Hines threw it away.

I am no football expert, but my question is: Why was a Touchdown called or why wasn't there at least a thorough review?

1 Answer 1


I'm not sure if you're asking if the ball remained in possession past the goal line, or if the ball has to be inside the sidelines. I'll address both.

All scoring plays are reviewed by the booth official. If they had a concern with the review, they would have signaled to the on-field referee to wait if more time was necessary. Presumably they were comfortable with seeing that the ball broke the plane of the goal while still in possession. That's all done behind the scenes, so it's not possible to know how much concern or what was seen.

enter image description here

From my viewing, the ball remains in his outstretched hand until after he reaches the end zone and the ball appears to have crossed the goal line. It looks quite precarious in this image, but it looked that way for some steps before the end zone as well. I don't see anything to suggest that he lost possession before scoring.

You mentioned the ball was "outside the field". As long as the ball crosses the plane in possession, and the possessing player is in the end zone, then the ball can be beyond the sideline but still a valid touchdown.

From NFL Rule 11-2-1, subpart (a) was met:

ARTICLE 1. TOUCHDOWN PLAYS. A touchdown is scored when:

(a) the ball is on, above, or behind the plane of the opponents’ goal line (extended) and is in possession of a runner who has advanced from the field of play into the end zone

It is only if the ball crosses the plane but if the runner does not reach the end zone that the position of the ball around the pylon is required.

This play is similar to approved ruling 3.16 (c):


Second-and-goal on B5. A2, running to his right, is contacted by B2, and as he is going down at the B1, he dives toward the pylon. The ball is held in his right hand extended over the out of bounds area but beyond the extended goal line, when his chest hits: ... (c) the ground in the end zone. The ball crossed the sideline at the B½-yard line, but it never went over the top of the pylon.



(c) Touchdown, as the ball broke the plane of the extended goal line, and the runner was not down until he was in the end zone. (3-39, 11-2-1)

  • Thank you! To clarify: My question was if the ball has to be inside the sidelines.
    – Kocki
    Commented Jan 10, 2023 at 5:59

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.