7

This could be a "hilarious" use of the Decision Review System, but nonetheless I want to know if it is possible.

Suppose both the batsmen run to the same end (mix-up, as commentators like to call it), and the fielding side puts down the wicket at one end. The on-field umpire declares one of the batsmen out. Can this batsman invoke DRS to challenge the umpire's decision, in effect, claiming that his partner should be out instead?

A non-hilarious scenario would be if a top-order batsman and a tailender gets involved in the mix-up, and the tailender is given out. The fielding captain might want to invoke the DRS to try to get the more skilled batsman out instead.

| improve this question | |
  • I've seen them go upstairs for this, you think that if it's close they'd do this – akkatracker Dec 20 '14 at 12:21
  • You are right, but that's different from using DRS. On-field umpires can seek help from the TV umpire when they please (subject to some restrictions), but I am not sure if players too can use DRS for that purpose. – Masked Man Dec 20 '14 at 14:11
  • A little off topic, but I remember a match where they spent a good 5 minutes working out which person was out after a major mix up. I think they were both at the same end. – tl8 Jan 21 '15 at 2:22
2

From Wikipedia:

A fielding team may use the system to dispute a "not out" call ...

and

At their discretion, field umpires may request the Third Umpire ... to determine run outs ...

These in combination would seem to suggest that the fielders can appeal the 'not-out' decision of the second batsman. The field umpires would then defer to the video umpire for a decision. Note that because UDRS requires clear contradiction to the original call, the video would have to definitively show the 'not-out' batsman being nearest to the crease. Any hint of the distances being indeterminate would result in upholding the decision and a loss of review for the fielding team.

| improve this answer | |
-1

On close runout calls On-filed umpires takes help from TV umpire, then there is no point of asking DRS (because the same answer will come even if he asks for DRS). Even in the confusing situation (both batsman are at the same end) can be handled by taking help of TV umpire.

| improve this answer | |
  • 2
    You are right, however, a lot of players have been very lousy with the use of DRS, often challenging blatantly obvious decisions only to look foolish on the big screen. Even if the on-field umpire doesn't refer to the TV umpire (because he thinks the decision is obvious enough), do the laws permit the players to challenge it? – Masked Man Dec 21 '14 at 16:26

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.